Story Prompts: What If?

If you want your students to write some stories – whether it’s for a brief exercise or the basis of a project – here are some what-if questions to get them thinking.

As your students narrow in on one of these what-if questions, there are other things to consider as well. We have some detail questions at the bottom of this post for that. But first, students should see which of these what-if questions strike their interest.

Also note that the questions target ‘you’, but students can apply this to characters they’ve created instead. They can write in either first-person or third-person.

What if your best friend or sibling became famous?
 
What if a secret government agency was after you?
 
What if you woke up one day and couldn’t remember the last three years of your life?
 
What if you and your friends were sent into the past?
 
What if you had a pet dragon or a pet unicorn?
 
What if you were chosen for a mission to travel to another galaxy?
 
What if your sports team entered a world-wide tournament, and every other team was ranked higher than yours?
 
What if the love of your life was forbidden from seeing you?
 
What if you and your friends were travelling through a jungle and came across the ruins of a lost civilization?
 
What if you figured out how to communicate effectively with animals?

Once a student chooses a what-if question to base a story around, they should then consider further questions to add details. The longer the story should be, the more detail questions they need to consider, and the more complex their answers should be. Here are some good detail questions for them:

  • What is the initial response for all characters involved? Once they settle into the new status quo, what’s their long-term response to the situation? (Different characters should respond in different ways).

  • How does this change affect the characters emotionally, intellectually, physically, socially, or financially?

  • In what ways is this change a good thing? In what ways is it bad?

  • How would the story play out differently if you used a different main character?

  • What are some things that could happen part-way through the story to make things worse? What can the main character(s) do by the end to make things better?

Get more with Insider Access

INCLUDING

Advanced Features in Student Projects

search and filter

planning info

AND

Extra Video Content

more How-to-Teach grammar videos*

with intros, instructions, and summaries

*compared to free resources

AND

Exclusive Supplemental Resources

slideshows

posters & handouts

bonus notes

Popular

Design a Town

Students create their own towns!  They need to consider where the town is, what it’s known for, how big the town is, and more.  They’ll need to figure out how many of each type of building to include.  Students reason with their group-mates and come to decisions.

Read More »
Class-Wide

Put On a Play

Students can learn a lot by putting on a play – not just reciting lines, but making a big production of it, involved in plenty of different aspects of the show.

Read More »
Class-Wide

Create a Choose-Your-Own-Adventure Story

This project is for practicing CONDITIONALS. Create a number of scenarios, each of which leads to two others. When you’ve finished, readers can choose which path they want to take, and by the end their story experience will be different from others.

Read More »
Topic-Based

Another Time, Another Place

This project is for practicing REPORTED SPEECH. Teams design a scenario, a setting, and a quote. Then other teams are challenged with reporting it in other settings/scenarios. See how many they can do in under a minute.

Read More »
WebQuests

WebQuest: Vampires

Vampires have been all the rage in fiction for the past couple decades.  As different authors and film-makers have made their own stories, many have made changes to the classic lore.  Let’s compare and contrast vampires from different stories.

Read More »

Share This Post