Show, Don’t Tell

This post serves as both a scene prompt and a writing tip.

A common adage among writers is “show, don’t tell”.  In other words, don’t explain everything that’s going on and everything character is thinking or feeling.  Instead, use actions or perception to reveal what’s going on with a character, internally or externally, and let the readers draw conclusions.  For instance, instead of saying “Yoniko was disappointed,” say “Yoniko’s smile faded as her shoulders dropped.”

Writing in this way prompts students to think of different ways to express the same thing.  Students will have to use expressions and imagery – like native speakers do in most situations – instead of being straightforward.  It may also expand their vocabulary usage (they’ve been using emotion words like ‘happy’ and ‘sad’ from a beginner level; let’s see them use other words that they should know individually in the same context to provide the same meaning with a richer reader experience).  Finally, it can help students with their reasoning skills.

 

Set the Stage

First, give the students something to write about.  It shouldn’t be a full story.  More advanced students might want to do a short scene, but otherwise just a moment in time will suffice.  Give the students a few things to work with:

  • a character – this could be a well-known character from pop-culture, or it could be original. The character could be well-defined or simple (eg. a police officer, an athletic woman, a boy who doesn’t fit in, etc.)

  • a location, and maybe a time – what’s going on around the character? Who and what can she/he interact with?

  • a focus – what is the character thinking about: work, a crush, an embarrassing situation, food? Maybe you prompt your students what a recent incident, and they have to tell you the character’s response to it. It’s up to you whether you dictate the emotion or let the students decide for themselves.

Now the students have something to write about.  Again, there’s no story progression (unless you want there to be), so what the students write might be pretty short.  A single paragraph may be enough.

Here are some things for your students to consider in order to indirectly (yet adequately) display how your character thinks and feels.

 

Perception Indicates Thought*

What the character is looking at (or smelling, tasting, hearing, or touching) should tell the reader what the character is thinking about.  If the writer tells us that the character can’t stop looking at his pretty classmate, we know he fancies her.  If the character is massaging her shoulder, maybe she’s thinking about a recent injury.  If he keeps looking at his watch, he’s more concerned with the future than the present.  If she’s smelling food, she’s probably hungry.

Breath Indicates Emotion*

How a character breathes reflects their immediate emotion.  A gasp indicates surprise.  A groan indicates annoyance.  A sigh indicates boredom, annoyance, or relief.  A gulp indicates dread.  A chuckle indicates amusement.  Held breath indicates fear or anticipation.

Body Language Indicates Emotion

Body language – including facial expressions – reveals emotions.  Confusion may be conveyed by scratching one’s head; disbelief by raising an eyebrow; suspicion by narrowing one’s eyes; eagerness by leaning forward; reservation by crossing one’s arms; etc.

Movement Indicates Intent*

How the characters moves, and what they move toward or from, informs the readers of the character’s intention.  If she moves toward another person, she intends to interact with him.  If he reaches out a hand, he probably wants to build up a relationship.  If she keeps shifting her weight, she might be looking for an excuse to leave.  If he stops walking, he’s probably hesitant.

I’ve given a bunch of examples of these four tools, but there are plenty of others I haven’t covered.  Before your student begin writing the actual scene, have a brainstorming session with them.  Body language alone could take half a lesson; there are so many options.

 

Share the Snapshots

Once every student has written their moment in time – or their snapshot of their character’s life – have each of them read it aloud.  If you’ve given everyone the same prompts, it’ll be interesting to compare how different students showed the same thoughts and feelings in different ways.

Another option is to give them all separate prompts.  Then after each students reads their snapshot aloud, the other students have to guess what the character was thinking about, and how they felt about it.

* Some of the ideas for how to show thought, emotion, and intent come from the advice of Mary Robinette Kowal, a writer and puppeteer.

Get more with Insider Access

INCLUDING

Advanced Features in Student Projects

search and filter

planning info

AND

Extra Video Content

more How-to-Teach grammar videos*

with intros, instructions, and summaries

*compared to free resources

AND

Exclusive Supplemental Resources

slideshows

posters & handouts

bonus notes

Class-Wide

Put On a Play

Students can learn a lot by putting on a play – not just reciting lines, but making a big production of it, involved in plenty of different aspects of the show.

Read More »

Clouds and Constellations

Different people can look up at the clouds or at the stars and see different things from the person standing next to them. In this project, students will have to defend what shapes they see by identifying its features.

Read More »

Offbeat Colors

Students should know the standard colors pretty well, but do they know colors like chartreuse, fuchsia, mauve, or periwinkle? This project is an opportunity to describe what’s new to them using elements that are more familiar.

Read More »
Writing Prompts

Missing Verse

Students analyze song lyrics to understand the tone, message, themes, and style, then write a missing third or fourth verse.

Read More »
Class-Wide

Crime & Justice

Re-enact a criminal case: craft the situation around a fictional robbery, conduct an investigation, and put on a mock trial. This project works best with multiple classes.

Read More »

Share This Post